Participatory environmental valuation of forest resources in the Aberdares, Kenya.
Download available
Download available
Download available
Helen Hambly's introduction focuses on the key viewpoint behind this book: that conventional approaches to the monitoring and evaluation of research and development projects have been dominated by Euro-American scientific perceptions of environmental and development change, using "top-down" approaches to data collection and analysis. The objective of the book therefore is to draw attention to grassroots indicators i.e. measures or signals of environmental quality or change formulated by individuals, households and communities, and derived from their local systems of observation, practice and indigenous knowledge. Looking first at the different motives for such indicators, the author goes on to introduce concepts of desertification and development, and grassroots indicators and desertification in Eastern and Southern Africa .
Download available
This brief note summarises the author's experience of using PRA and RAAKs (Rapid Appraisal of Agricultural Knowledge Systems) as a research method in exploring water users' perspective on performance indicators of an irrigation system. The result of a participatory study conducted by IIMI-Pakistan are discussed. The study outlines the performance indicators developed by water users and local responses to compensate for poor water performance. The potential of using PRA in large-scale irrigation systems are assessed and the need to recognise the relevance of incorporating various participatory research methodologies.
Download available
This article shares the author's experiences in promoting gender equality in the æSupport to Generation and Transfer of Agricultural Technology ProjectÆ (PRODETEC) in Nicaragua. They represent important lessons for gender sensitive participatory diagnosis and are applicable to other organisations. The article presents the background to the project, and its two main approaches: farming systems and gender. Rapid gender analysis was carried out at the start of the project and this explored the broad differences between male and female production systems. This is followed by a participatory diagnosis during the planning process phase. The article stresses the need for gender equality in the project, especially in participation in decision making. It offers practical tips on when and how participation may happen. It also offers a clue to increasing female participation as discussion by separate men and womensÆ groups. In conclusion, the article advises that a high or low profile gender approach should be adopted according to what is appropriate and sensitive to the context.
Download available
Download available
This paper is about the use of PRA in exploring indigenous technical knowledge which could be useful in the management of natural resources. The ways of discovering such knowledge, such as folklore, from the elders and how participatory research can help in understanding the indigenous knowledge systems are explained. Specific examples suggesting the harmony between nature and people in the old days and erosion of these institutions after the establishment of formal legal systems at the beginning of this century are discussed.
Download available
This paper gives a comparative overview of the use of objective/quantitative and subjective/narrative information in understanding the historical land use changes in Uganda. Data obtained from using PRA/RRA methods and from a longitudinal survey are compared and contrasted. Further explanations are provided as to how and why the discrepancies arose and how they were resolved by the use of various triangulation methods. The paper emphasises the importance of understanding the local perceptions and in taking proper care in interpreting them.
Download available
This note describes in detail how different research methods - such as RRA, PRA, participatory decision making and ecological economics - could be integrated to make the research relevant to the needs of local people, planners and academics. The importance of selecting a particular research method or a combination of methods depending on the specific situation of the research site is highlighted. The actual process involved in conducting the research are explained. Multidisciplinary participatory research can help generate rich findings and may be useful in linking micro-macro planning, the note concludes.
Download available
This brief article describes the strengths of local participation and the limits of local knowledge in the context of a long term research and development project in Eastern Amazonia which focuses on the subsistence and economic value of non-timber forest products for rural communities. The benefits and shortcomings of local knowledge to ecological research are outlined. Suggestions are made on how the significant gaps in local knowledge can be complemented by more conventional biophysical methods. The use of long-term ecological methods along with PRA are described while highlighting the utility of PRA when used in conjunction with other quantitative methods. The paper also points out the dilemma facing the researcher, that is whether to give priority to publishing research results for an outside audience, or making the information accessible to the local people.
Download available
This brief note describes the principles and practice of integrated pest management (IPM) as part of the FAO country programme in South and South East Asia. The objectives of the programmes are outlined, emphasising the importance of minimising the use of pesticides in rice crops and encouraging farmers to learn about their agro- ecosystem. Procedures involved in training the farmers to use transects method are described along with the outcome of the training. Although the main part of the training methodology applied is said to be the transect and the use of the word PRA is made once in the note, the whole emphasis of the paper seems to be on imparting knowledge from the trainers to the farmers rather than on a two-way learning process.
Download available
This paper describes the use of a variety of research methods including PRA, RRA in exploring the complex issue of soil fertility in the hills of Nepal. The parallel use of participatory and formal research methods in the research process are described. The results obtained from different methods are compared and contrasted illustrating the complexity of the problem of soil fertility. The use of complementary approaches that combine the qualitative strength of PRA with the quantitative data obtained from conventional surveys are highlighted. The challenges, as outlined in the paper, are to identify and develop complementary methods and to maintain an optimum balance between the qualitative and quantitative concerns.
Download available
This article highlights the danger of using quantitative research methods alone, based on the experiences of a research project examining sustainable management of mangroves in El Tamarindo, El Salvador. The important contribution PRA techniques made to the quality of the research and also how they reduced overall project costs are outlined. Moreover, the article describes how the PRA stimulated community action, reactivating the pre-existing Ecological Committee of El Tamarindo and the production of an educational booklet.
Download available
Report on PRA carried out by World Bank in ten villages in Mali to complement quantitative data previously collected on the red meat sub-sector for policy development purposes.
Download available
This paper describes how the combination of chemical soil and water analyses and PRA exercises were found to be complementary methods in assessing the magnitude of the pollution problem caused by the tannery industry in Kamtchipuram village, Tamil Nadu.
Download available
This article describes how mapping of local peoples perceptions of child malnutrition was used to improve the quality of focus group discussions. Time was taken at the beginning of the study to understand all the words related to malnutrition and ensure that all members of the group had the same definition, since in the urban setting there was no one single language which all members shared.